So are you a libertarian?
Published by Yazad Jal March 8th, 2004 in LibertarianThe first ever quiz I took to find out whether I was a libertarian or not was the World’s Smallest Political Quiz (WSPQ) Well, as I already considered myself not just libertarian but anarcho-capitalist (I had just finished reading the Machinery of Capitalism), I scored a perfect 100 on both personal and economic self government aspects of the quiz.
Later on, I came across Politopia — the land of custom made government. But naturally, my score was unchanged. This site had more colour and was a tad more sophisticated. Look at the map below — the star is where I “live” in Politopia–the Northwest, yup right next to Ayn Rand. 
There’s a nice explanation of the concept as well as a list of many other such quizzes here. (But read it after taking the quiz.)
While doing my regular blog browsing I came upon another quiz from the Agitator, Radley Balko’s blog. Devised by Bryan Caplan of George Mason University, the Libertarian Purity Test (LPT) claims to give a clearer breakdown between hard and soft-core libertarians.
Radley scores a 98. I thought the perfect score was 100. It’s actually 160. I scored a 147. This is what Caplan has to say about the score
You are nearly a perfect libertarian, with a tiny number of blind spots. Think about them, then take the test over again. On the other hand, if you scored this high, you probably have a good libertarian objection to my suggested libertarian answer. :-)
So far so good. But these quizzes aren’t blemish free.
- They are largely US centric. Policy issues like social security or military bases in foreign countries are unique to the US. LPT asks you to judge specific US government policies with the implicit assumption that you’re a US citizen.
- The design and ordering of questions and answers is overly simplistic. Politopia gives 5 multiple choices for each question. One answer is most libertarian, one most anti-libertarian and the rest soemwhere in between. That’s ok. But they are specifically ordered and that order is maintained throughout the quiz. So if you know that say answer #3 is most libertarian, you can blindly click on 3 to get a high score on being a libertarian. Makes it like a Cosmo quiz. “If you score mostly A’s, the guy loves you, if you scored mostly B’s, dump him, etc”
WSPQ is brief and direct. That’s why I still prefer it. The explanations however are far better in Politopia and LPT. Caplan even gives you a statistical break-up of those who took the quiz. So go forth and get yourself “tested”!
Update: The Libertarian Purity Test seems to be making waves all over the blogosphere. Tim Lambert and Joe Carter are keeping score!
10 Responses to “So are you a libertarian?”
- 1 Trackback on Mar 9th, 2004 at 6:24 am
- 2 Trackback on Mar 9th, 2004 at 6:43 pm
- 3 Trackback on Mar 9th, 2004 at 10:23 pm
Makes it like a Cosmo quiz. “If you score mostly A’s, the guy loves you, if you scored mostly B’s, dump him, etc.
Every time someone takes those women’s mag quizes, the world loses a few brain cells. :)
I’m of course a libertarian and a card-carrying capitalist, though I don’t share your anarchist leanings.
Hi! Havent read the book yet, so can you explain to me, lucidly, what Anarcho Capitalism means. I think I know, but it wouldnt hurt to know better.
BTW - My WSPQ Score -
“Your Personal Self-Government Score is 90%.
Your Economic Self-Government Score is 80%. ”
So what does it mean?
My post on what is anarcho capitalism is long overdue. Well, your score is puts you squarely in the “libertarian” bracket. You give up 10% of personal freedoms and 20% of economic freedoms to a govt. / state. That’s a very small figure. WSPQ also has a grid where they fit these scores in.
I took the Politopia quiz too. I end up just below Ayn Rand, and a little ot the left. LIke maybe a millimeter to the left of Ayn Rand.
SO that would mean the same thing too, wouldnt it? I see you are round about there too.
But I need the answer to anarcho capitalism to answer the third quiz.
Let me google for it. Unless you wanna kick in and post it soon
;-P
Have a look at Bryan Caplan’s Anarchist Theory FAQ. It deals with anarcho-capitalism as well as leftist anarchism.
Some chapters of Machinery of Capitalism are webbed on David Friedman’s site.
LPT - 105!
Political Compass
Try that quiz.
Nice one.
[Edited by Ravikiran to convert the URL into a link, as the long URL was screwing up the formatting of the main page. ]
(Link from Null Pointer)